STRIKING THE RIGHT CHORD: BETWEEN INNOVATION AND AUTHENTICITY

As artificial intelligence begins to compose melodies and replicate human voices, the world of music stands at a compelling crossroads. Once rooted in raw emotion and personal storytelling, music now faces the risk of becoming a product shaped by algorithms and code

 With the boundary between human creativity and machine output rapidly fading, a pressing question emerges: can authenticity survive in an age of artificial sound?

“AI can serve as an aid and tool to collate ideas,” says musician Ranjani Sivakumar, “but the essence of art lies in the human spirit. I am not being merely poetic when I say this.”

Ranjani Sivakuma

Praveen Sparsh, Mridangam artiste, multi-percussionist and music producer, observes, “Music is a vast landscape, and AI’s impact differs across genres. In traditional forms like Carnatic music, AI’s role is still minimal and poses little threat. But in genres such as electronic or digital music production, AI continues a long-standing evolution—much like the shift from live orchestras to sampled sounds and virtual instruments. Mainstream music cultures are adapting in their own ways, and ultimately, it’s a trade-off—each genre must find its balance with artistic integrity.”

As AI advances in composition and production, it may also influence how we perceive musicians and their work. Ranjani explains, “While AI can help streamline ideas, when it comes to composing or playing instruments, the human touch offers something truly distinctive. It’s that je ne sais quoi—the intangible essence that allows music to move and connect with the soul.”

Praveen Sparsh

Could AI challenge human music producers? Possibly. But Praveen puts it in perspective: “For beginners, AI can help spark ideas and build confidence. For professionals, though, true artistry comes from collaboration and lived experience. While AI can mimic, it lacks the depth of human expression. Those in search of authenticity will always seek out real artists with real stories.”

Music is powerful because it forms emotional connections—through melody, voice, or meaning. But if AI creates music, will that connection feel real, or merely mechanical? Ranjani believes AI doesn’t necessarily diminish emotional impact. “It’s human qualities—like a unique voice or even imperfections—that make art beautiful,” she says.

Praveen offers a nuanced view: “It’s complicated. If an AI-generated song triggers nostalgia—a deeply human emotion tied to memory—it can still evoke feeling. The fact that AI can recreate emotional connections, even partially, is unsettling.”

Concerns persist about whether AI could surpass humans in creative fields. Ranjani is clear: “True artistic creation comes from a soulful place—something AI inherently lacks. Digital creators are artists too, but it’s all about balance. It’s the dose that makes the poison.”

On the subject of collaboration, Ranjani is optimistic: “AI can be a powerful tool to shape and develop ideas. Used thoughtfully, it’s a win-win. I watched an episode of Black Mirror where AI was used to recreate an old film—it was both fascinating and disturbing.”

New technology always brings a mix of hope and apprehension. Praveen reflects, “Art connects people and creates something that moves us.” But he also warns, “There’s a danger that music could become superficial due to AI—leading to shallow audience engagement.”

Ranjani sees potential in AI as a support mechanism. “It can simplify complex processes—be it idea development or mind mapping,” she says. “But art is about self-expression. Without the ‘self’, it’s no longer art. It’s more than a commodity—the joy of creating is irreplaceable.”

AI’s growing role also raises concerns about its impact on independent artists. Ranjani adds, “There’s beauty in the human voice and in so-called imperfections. Look at nature—what some perceive as flaws, others celebrate as uniqueness.”

Praveen acknowledges both the promise and the pressure: “Every innovation brings opportunity, but also challenges. When virtual instruments emerged, people feared they’d replace musicians. The real questions are—‘Do I need it?’ and ‘Will it enhance my music?’ Trends come and go, but an independent artist must rise above the noise and stay true to their core.”

He shares his personal stance: “I use AI for promotional tasks—like quick Instagram captions or proofreading. But not in music. Everyone must decide for themselves when and how they want to engage with it.”

As AI becomes more deeply embedded in music, it presents both a creative companion and a philosophical dilemma. While it can support the artistic process, the soul of music—its emotion, imperfections, and humanity—remains irreplaceable.

The future of music may not be about choosing between AI and humans, but about how they can coexist in harmony—without losing the heart of what makes music resonate.